News / Photojournalist wins out-of-court settlement from Metropo...


Photojournalist wins out-of-court settlement from Metropolitan Police in assault case  

25/02/2008

Photojournalist Marc Vallée has accepted an apology and out-of-court settlement from the Metropolitan Police today (25/2), further to issuing proceedings against Sir Ian Blair, Commissioner of Police for the Metropolis for "Battery" (assault) and breaches of the Human Rights Act, relating to freedom of expression and assembly.

Mr Vallée, a member of the National Union of Journalists, International Federation of Journalists and the British Press Photographers’ Association, was taking photographs of the ‘Sack Parliament’ demonstration protest in Parliament Square on 9 October 2006.

Mr Vallée received injuries further to action by Metropolitan Police officers, which resulted in an ambulance attending to give urgent attention and then treatment at St Thomas’ hospital.

Mr Vallée has received a written apology and an out-of-court settlement. His legal costs for pursuing the action will also be met by the police.

Ms Chez Cotton, Mr. Vallée’s solicitor, said:

“This was an extremely unpleasant incident. Neither the Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police or his officers has any legal power, moral responsibility or political responsibility to prevent or restrict what the media record. Mr Vallée is a well-respected photojournalist, lawfully present to photograph a political protest outside parliament, yet he was brutally prevented from doing so by the police. It is right that Mr Vallée has received an apology, an out of court settlement and that his legal costs will be met by the police.”

Mr. Jeremy Dear, General Secretary of the National Union of Journalists, said:

“Marc will be pleased to have finally got an apology from the police, but it is no cause for celebration. It is disgraceful that the police brutally obstructed a member of the press from reporting on a political demonstration. Press freedom is a central tenet of our democracy so Marc Vallée’s treatment by the police is deeply worrying. The Met needs to take a close look at what must be done to ensure its officers respect journalists’ rights.”

Mr Chris Atkins, director of the BAFTA nominated hit feature film documentary “Taking Liberties”, who witnessed the incident, said:

“Seeing photojournalist Marc Vallée assaulted by uniformed officers for simply photographing protesters outside parliament was appalling, and a sad reflection on the political policing that is now part of everyday Britain. Marc’s case is a stark reminder that peaceful protest, and the reporting of it, is very much under threat in this country."

Mr Mark Thomas, comic, activist and a writer said:

"Marc's win shows that police simply cannot attack journalists and get away with it. The Met should be ashamed that the case had to be taken on in the first place, physically assaulting journalists in the pursuit of their job is an outrageous and vile act that smacks of the worst kind of censorship and bully boy tactics. One can only hope that the Met will learn from this and refrain from beating up members of the press in future."

Mr Vallee was represented by Nick Stanage , instructed by Chez Cotton.

........................................................................................................................................

Quick links

> 25/2/08 Photojournalist wins police apology (The Guardian)

> About Marc Vallée: Marc Vallée is a member of the National Union of Journalists, International Federation of Journalists and the British Press Photographers' Association. See: www.marcvallee.co.uk and www.marcvallee.co.uk/blog_250208.html

> 18/09/2007 Press photographer sues Met over demo



Right menu

  What's New?  
 

5/2/10 GCN mental capacity seminar announced (23/3/10)

4/2/10 Mark George to speak at US death penalty event

January 2010 Prison law update

January 2010 Criminal law update

18/01/10 Camille Warren joins chambers

18/01/10 Prison law - Challenging NOMS and UK Board Agency agreement on segregation of foreign nationals

16/12/09 Third party support and/or joint sponsorship permissible for entry clearance applications under Rules 281, 297 & 317

16/12/09 Sonny Lodge public inquiry - final report released

15/12/09 Appeal against 2004 convictions allowed - referral by Criminal Cases Review Commission

11/12/09 Manchester City Council –v- Pinnock - Permission to appeal granted

3/12/09 Prison law - 'Challenging Deportation'

30/11/09 Prison JR: SSJ acted unlawfully in IPP transfer

17/11/09 Chambers & Partners 2010 recommendations

12/11/09 Mark George QC on Judge's decision in child rape case

November 2009 Housing bulletin

6/11/09 James Stark to speak at HLPA event on 15/12

30/10/09 Three new members join GCN

9/10/09 Sarah Daley 'the issues of best value tendering in criminal legal aid'

2/10/09 ‘Letter from America’ Kate Stone’s Pegasus scholarship

1/10/09 UK Supreme Court Opens

28/9/09 Legal 500 ratings

23/9/09 Pete Weatherby on assisted suicide guidelines

14/9/09 Appeal against sentencing affecting HDC upheld

11/9/09 Prison JR on reasons for Cat A ERC decisions

9/9/09 Michael Shields released; first ever British pardon of someone convicted abroad (+ media coverage links)

4/9/09 James Stark on "homeless at home"

19/8/09 Prison JR challenges Cat A review decision

16/8/09 Pete Weatherby on "Right to review reviewed"

7/8/09 Latest equal pay case

31/7/09 James Stark on "Reasonable Occupational Continuation"

23/7/09 Sex offenders register without mechanism for review is "incompatible" with HRA 1998

22/7/09 Unlawful killing verdict for aid worker killed in India

17/7/09 House of Lords to consider "third party support"

17/7/09 Prison JR quashes re-categorisation and HDC decision

16/7/09 Who is "Lawyer of the week" and which GCN barrister gets a mention?