News / Indeterminate ethics of sentences


Indeterminate ethics of sentences  

12/05/2008

Recent reports of prison overcrowding and challenges to the lawfulness of sentences of imprisonment for public protection (IPPs) have thrust indeterminate sentences into the limelight. Farrhat Arshad and Kate Stone provide a view on why they are so widely imposed and how they can be avoided in this months' Independent Lawyer (May 2008).

The article covers:

  • The regime
  • The assessment
  • The sentence
  • The scope
  • Measures practitioners can take to protect their clients
  • An assessment of caselaw relating to The Court of Appeal's response to IPP sentence challenges (including for robbery and sexual offences)

Farrhat and Kate conclude:

"The assessment of dangerousness for the purposes of this sentencing regime is a fact-specific exercise and it seems that the Court of Appeal may be reluctant to interfere unless the sentencing judge has departed from the approach set out in Lang or his/her conclusion is unsupported by the information before the court.

Unless the government wishes to continue to see prisons straining at the seams and are unable to offer proper rehabilitative measures to prisoners, radical changes must be made so that indeterminate sentences are reserved for those who can properly be described as dangerous"

For more details about this article please contact Helen Ray on 0161 236 1840.



Right menu

  What's New?  
 

13/5/08 Bulletin on new AIT (Procedure) (Amendment) rules

12/5/08 Independent Lawyer article on IPPs

30/4/08 M1 widening protesters' prosection dismissed

21/4/08 Sonia Birdee joins chambers

17/4/08 Moran judgment (refuges & homelessness)

7/4/08 Nina Grahame joins chambers [Times Online]

10/4/08 Marathon Ben

2/4/08 Vicky Robinson inquest

19/3/08 Entrenched tolerated trespassers

14/3/08 Police officers on juries?

6/3/08 new homepage

February 2008 Criminal law update

26/2/08 Levi Bellfield legal context (Radio 5 Live)

26/2/08 Driver's "reasonable excuse" for no specimen

25/2/08 Admin Court ruling on HDC for prisoners

25/2/08 Settlement, apology and costs from Met Police

24/2/08 LCN DNA: Unreliable evidence?

12/2/08 Andrew Jones inquest

6/2/08 Use of intercept evidence (BBC R4)

3/2/08 Criticism of inquest jury ban proposals (BBC R4)

1/2/08 Walker and James (IPP) judgment

Most read in 2007

06/12/07 Inquest verdict condemns Prison Service

28/11/07 House of Lords allows asylum appeal

22/11/07 Asbestos and mesothelioma ruling

20/11/07 Government appeals ruling on IPPs

9/11/07 Chambers & Partners recommends...

30/10/07 HoL permission for tolerated trespassers

30/10/07 Dreadlocks, Rastafarians, Religious Belief

24/10/07 Manchester Civil Justice Centre opens

1/10/07 Who is a "Future star of the bar"?

24/9/07 Legal 500 ratings

13/9/07 GCN shortlisted for Chambers Bar Award 2007

4/6/07 Michael Shields

4/6/07 Terrorism Trial in Manchester

14/11/06 Tsfayo v UK (ECHR Art 6)

18/10/06 House of Lords refugee victory

18/08/06 Control Orders "deprivation of liberty" ruling

12/04/06 Is oral sex in a public place illegal?

> Go to News headlines