News / John Hirst and "Rocky" found not guilty


John Hirst and "Rocky" found not guilty  

09/09/2008

John Hirst who was released in 2004 after serving 25 years in prison for manslaughter and who spent much of the latter part of his sentence litigating with some success against the government and prison service has won his latest encounter with the authorities.

It seems that a number of park keepers at a local park where Mr Hirst enjoyed exercising his dog had found out about his past and resented his using the park. After an altercation earlier this year in which it was alleged that his dog Rocky had bitten a park keeper Mr Hirst was arrested and charged under the Dangerous Dogs Act s.3 with having a dog "dangerously out of control and causing injury", an offence which could have resulted in a death sentence for Rocky and a further charge of common assault to cover an allegation that the dog had bitten the park keeper in response to direct command to "kill him" from Mr Hirst. It should be pointed out that Rocky is a cross breed Labrador/Retriever and more likely to lick you to death than do any other lasting damage!

The prosecution had originally lined up all their heavy artillery including a bad character application relating to previous alleged incidents of bad behaviour by Rocky, with supporting evidence at least twice as lengthy as the evidence to be used to support the present charges, and an application for an ASBO in the event of conviction. The bad character application was resisted on the basis, inter alia, that the bad character of the dog was not admissible even under the wide ranging terms of section 101 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 and even before the trial as due to begin the prosecution had evidently thought better of that part of the case.

The allegation of common assault was then found to be untenable as well when the prosecution's dog behaviour expert agreed with the defence expert that a dog like Rocky wouldn't have the faintest idea what the command to "kill" meant! When the judge then weighed in with the view that the time of the Crown Court might be better spent on other cases the prosecution were left to enquire whether Mr Hirst would consider accepting a bind-over which he agreed to on the basis that not guilty verdicts were entered on both counts of the indictment.

The case is a good example of why it is not a good idea to overcharge (a minor public order charge would have been more appropriate) and then to seek to blow the case out of all proportion especially against such an experienced litigator as Mr Hirst.

Mr Hirst was represented by Mark George instructed by Frances Taylor of Harrison Bundey Solicitors in Leeds.

......................................................................................................................................

Quick links

> 12/09/2008 - Man's dog "did not attack park warden" (Hull Daily Mail)



Right menu

  What's New?  
 

Save UK Justice resources
- what's it all about?
- Consultation responses 

Latest GCN legal bulletins
Housing Team Bulletin (Feb 2014)
Crime (December 2013)

LASPO resources
Quick Guide to LASPO 2012 Part 3 (re: crime)
Quick Guide to LASPO 2012 for Housing Law
Quick Guide to LASPO 2012 for Immigration Law

Now on Twitter @gcnchambers  

29/7/14 Hilllsborough: latest

22/7/14 Unlawful killing verdict in toddler inquest

22/7/14 CPAG test case on Council Tax Reduction

21/7/14 "Bricks and mortar" interim accommodation

16/7/14 Lucy Mair on "Little more than rough justice" for Litigants in Person following legal aid cuts (The Justice Gap)

10/7/14 Zimran Samuel expert evidence in Pakistan CG case

9/6/14 Vijay Jagadesham on students and veracity checks (Free Movement)

19/5/14 Supreme Court hears IPP Article 5 challenge

24/4/14 GCN's Lucy Mair shortlisted for LALY award

24/4/14 David Campion awarded Master of Laws in Employment Law

28/3/2014 Angry GCN Members oppose CBA decision to discontinue protests against legal aid cuts

19/3/2014 Lucy Mair contributes to BHRC Report on Torture and Sexual Violence in Sri Lanka   

17/3/2014 Zimran Samuel contributes to BHRC report on human rights inquiry into Violence Against Woman and Girls 

12/3/14 Kerry Smith Returns from maternity leave 5th May

11/3/14 Garden Court North Sponsor Legal Justice Together: Call for Action Conference

03/3/14 Scott v Pacific Mortgages and Others in Supreme Court

28/2/14 Tom Royston on Bedroom Tax: Update and Winning Bedroom Tax Cases

20/2/14 Police Call Handler Unanimously Acquitted of Misconduct in Public Office

02/01/2014 Criminal Barristers National Protest

19/12/2013 Breach of PSED in the provision of women’s approved premises  

18/12/2013 GCN Chambers welcomes vote of no confidence in Law Society leadership in Legal Aid fight 

12/12/13  Richard Brigden acting for anti drilling protesters  

3/12/2013 MoJ VHCC list clarification 

28/11/2013 David Campion - Judgment in EAT case on employment status of a CoE priest handed down

21/11/13 Matthew Stanbury- Divisional Court reiterate that there is no power to lay an information outside the six-month time-limit

19/11/13 Phillip McLeish - Judgment in Leicester City Council v Shearer