News / Court of Appeal upholds sex offenders register ruling


Court of Appeal upholds sex offenders register ruling  

23/07/2009

The Court of Appeal (Civil Division) has upheld the important High Court ruling that indefinite notification requirements for convicted sex offenders without review is incompatible with Article 8 of the Convention on human rights.

JF & Anor,R (on the application of) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2009] EWCA Civ 792 (23 July 2009); [2009] WLR(D)253

> judgment

> WLR(D) law report

Following the hearing on 9/7/09 before Dyson LJ, Kay LJ and Hooper LJ, the judgment concluded:

"[65.] ...Parliament's objective in establishing the Sex Offenders Register, was to assist the police to detect and prevent sexual offending. This is an objective which all right-minded people would applaud without hesitation or qualification. But for the reasons that we have given, a scheme which obliges offenders who are sentenced to 30 months' detention or more to remain on the Register for the rest of their lives without any possibility of review, even if they can clearly demonstrate that they are no longer a risk, does nothing to promote that laudable objective and, in our view, it is disproportionate for that reason..."

The Secretary of State's appeal against the declaration of incompatibility pursuant to section 4 of the Human Rights Act 1998 was dismissed. The Secretary of State is seeking permission to appeal to the House of Lords, but unless the declaration is quashed, Parliament will have to amend the legislation to provide for reviews.

Tim Owen QC and Pete Weatherby of GCN appeared for Angus Thompson instructed by Irwin Mitchell Solicitors

Quick links

> 19/12/08 - High Court ruling on sex offenders register

Media coverage

> 24/7/09 - Sex ofender register for life "breaches rights" of rapists and paedophiles (The Telegraph)



Right menu

  What's New?  
 

21/11/11 European citizenship

18/11/11 Surveillance laws

16/11/11 Prison distance learning policy unlawful (HMP Wakefield)

11/11/11 L'pool 'Bloody Sunday'

3/11/11 Mark George QC called to Bar of Northern Ireland

28/10/11 Indirect discrimination

26/10/11 Chambers UK 2012

21/10/11 Philip McLeish joins

18/10/11 Squatting reform

18/10/11 Riot appeals

13/10/11 AXA asbestos appeal

12/10/11 New Ogden Tables

10/10/11 Sarah Daley nomination

6/10/11 Supergrass evidence

3/10/11 Parole: "mistake of fact"

29/8/11 Manuel Valle execution

28/9/11 Teacher cleared (Wilson)

22/9/11 Legal 500 2011

21/9/11 Manchester Legal Walk

4/8/11 Learning disability in prison

3/8/11 Criminal law update

2/8/11 Sara Woodhouse Davie

22/7/11 Murder of burglar (ITV)

21/7/11 Trafficking offences

12/7/11 Joint enterprise

4/7/11 Prison law bulletin

30/6/11 3rd party race discrim

21/6/11 LASPO Bill

16/6/11 Facebook juror

14/6/11 Sex Offenders register

31/5/11 Retention of DNA

26/5/11 Fasting prisoner, Art 9

23/5/11 Sentence Calculation

19/5/11 Lawful containment

12/5/11 Compensation for miscarriages of justice

5/5/11 Vulnerable witnesses

3/5/11 PAS Guardian article

20/4/11 Proportionate recall

31/3/11 Makisi (Homelessness)

29/3/11 Teacher arrest unlawful

29/3/11 Mark Barlow (Radio 4)

28/3/11 Fresh Claims

17/3/11 Hearsay (Confiscation)

3/3/11 Sex Offenders Register

Feb 2011 Housing bulletin

22/2/11 Death Penalty training

14/2/11 Bahrain: BHRC report

11/2/11 Damages: Art 5(1)

8/2/11 Litigants in person

3/2/11 Theft of illegal property?

1/2/11 EHRC Preferred Counsel

26/1/11 Jared Ficklin joins

24/1/11 FNP recategorisation

20/1/11 Art 6(1) and disclosure

7/1/11 Mark Barlow in Rook & Ward on Sexual Offences (4th)

4/1/11 Osborn & Booth

Immigration Law & Practice (8th)

9/12/10 Reverse burden of proof

30/11/10 Whole-life tariff

25/11/10 Prisoner voting

23/11/10 Death at HMP Wymott

23/11/10 Sexual orientation

3/11/10 Pinnock judgment

28/10/10 Raymond Morris

27/10/10 Arizona execution

27/10/10 Matthew Stanbury called to Bar of Northern Ireland

25/10/10 Immigration detention for mentally ill (Anam)

22/10/10 Disab.Eq.Duty (Pieretti)

1/10/10 Equality Act 2010

9/9/10 Succession provisions

Sep 2010 Immigration Bulletin

16/8/10 Cat A (Krstic)

26/7/10 Crossfire shooting

23/7/10 HM (Malawi)

30/6/10 Noone and HDC

23/6/10 Out-of-time appeal IPP

7/6/10 Rape anonymity

18/5/10 US Supreme Court outlaws life without parole for non-homicide juveniles

30/4/10 Whole life tariff quashed

19/4/10 Hannah McIntyre

25/2/10 Assisted suicide

16/12/09 Third party support

16/12/09 Sonny Lodge inquiry

5/12/09 2004 conviction unsafe

30/11/09 IPP transfer- Guittard

9/10/09 BVT: LAG article

2/10/09 "Letter from America"

9/9/09 Michael Shields released

8/7/09 COPD compensation

16/6/09 Murder quashed

22/4/09 Mc'r Admin Court

30/3/09 New QC

12/11/08 Pro-bono hero

23/10/08 "Small but beautiful"

17/9/08 Historic allegations

9/9/08 Dog "Rocky" not guilty

4/7/08 Posthumous appeal

14/3/08 Police on juries?

24/2/08 LCN DNA: Unreliable?

22/11/07 Mesothelioma ruling

12/04/06 Oral sex in public

> Go to News headlines