News / Appeal against 2004 convictions allowed on referral from...


Appeal against 2004 convictions allowed on referral from the Criminal Cases Review Commission  

15/12/2009

R v France CCA 15/12/09

On a referral from the Criminal Cases Review Commission, the Court of Appeal allowed an appeal against convictions on six counts of rape and indecent assaults following the appellant’s trial in 2004.

Moses LJ held that evidence of the defendant’s longstanding congenital penile curvature, which was clearly available to defence counsel at the original trial but had not been adduced before the jury, was likely to have had a significant effect upon the course of the trial and the jury verdicts.

The complainant had confirmed in cross examination that he had observed nothing unusual in the appearance of the appellant's genitalia; despite this response, no evidence of the significant curvature was subsequently adduced. Efforts to obtain an explanation for the omission from trial counsel had failed to shed any light on the issue.

Given that medical evidence was now available to support the significant visible curvature and the duration of the condition, and given that the appellant could not be blamed for not volunteering evidence where he had never been asked about it, the Court held that they could find no rational explanation for the failure to adduce this evidence and the convictions were unsafe.

Nina Grahame appeared for the appellant, instructed by Mark Newby of Jordans Solicitors LLP , Doncaster .



Right menu

  What's New?  
 

Save UK Justice resources
- what's it all about?
- Consultation responses 

Latest GCN legal bulletins
Housing Team Bulletin (Feb 2014)
Crime (December 2013)

LASPO resources
Quick Guide to LASPO 2012 Part 3 (re: crime)
Quick Guide to LASPO 2012 for Housing Law
Quick Guide to LASPO 2012 for Immigration Law

Now on Twitter @gcnchambers  

22/7/14 CPAG test case on Council Tax Reduction

21/7/14 "Bricks and mortar" interim accommodation

16/7/14 Lucy Mair on "Little more than rough justice" for Litigants in Person following legal aid cuts (The Justice Gap)

10/7/14 Zimran Samuel expert evidence in Pakistan CG case

9/6/14 Vijay Jagadesham on students and veracity checks (Free Movement)

19/5/14 Supreme Court hears IPP Article 5 challenge

24/4/14 GCN's Lucy Mair shortlisted for LALY award

24/4/14 David Campion awarded Master of Laws in Employment Law

28/3/2014 Angry GCN Members oppose CBA decision to discontinue protests against legal aid cuts

19/3/2014 Lucy Mair contributes to BHRC Report on Torture and Sexual Violence in Sri Lanka   

17/3/2014 Zimran Samuel contributes to BHRC report on human rights inquiry into Violence Against Woman and Girls 

12/3/14 Kerry Smith Returns from maternity leave 5th May

11/3/14 Garden Court North Sponsor Legal Justice Together: Call for Action Conference

03/3/14 Scott v Pacific Mortgages and Others in Supreme Court

28/2/14 Tom Royston on Bedroom Tax: Update and Winning Bedroom Tax Cases

20/2/14 Police Call Handler Unanimously Acquitted of Misconduct in Public Office

02/01/2014 Criminal Barristers National Protest

19/12/2013 Breach of PSED in the provision of women’s approved premises  

18/12/2013 GCN Chambers welcomes vote of no confidence in Law Society leadership in Legal Aid fight 

12/12/13  Richard Brigden acting for anti drilling protesters  

3/12/2013 MoJ VHCC list clarification 

28/11/2013 David Campion - Judgment in EAT case on employment status of a CoE priest handed down

21/11/13 Matthew Stanbury- Divisional Court reiterate that there is no power to lay an information outside the six-month time-limit

19/11/13 Phillip McLeish - Judgment in Leicester City Council v Shearer