News / Advocacy: How to handle a vulnerable witness


Advocacy: How to handle a vulnerable witness  

05/05/2011

The Advocacy Training Council recently published a report on the first major research project in England & Wales specifically directed to considering the training barristers need to develop the right skills and understanding in how to interview, examine and cross-examine vulnerable witnesses, victims and defendants. Nina Grahame ,of GCN, was interviewed for Lexis Nexis Current Awareness (published 3/5/11) about what practitioners can learn from the report.

Extracts from the article as follows:

What problems most concerned practitioners? Grahame observes that issues such as “the possible ‘ticketing’ of specialist advocates was broadly supported but practicalities such as funding for training and restricted access to representation caused concerns.” Other practical problems of concern involved the “problems of travel, tiredness and concentration for young defendants”.

What were the most important recommendations for practitioners to deal with some of the problems raised in the report? Grahame says that “compulsory training for advocates together with the use of the ‘Toolkit’ included in the report, a duty of disclosure going beyond the legal minimum in cases involving vulnerable witnesses, and the drafting of an ‘Agreed Practice Note’ for the jury setting out details of the difficulties likely to be encountered during questioning” are the key recommendations.

...

However, Grahame points out that “extended disclosure will require more detailed guidelines.”

“The Agreed Practice Note may sound innocuous but is likely to raise significant problems in practice, where agreement between the parties as to the nature and extent of defendant’s or witness’ difficulties will often be contentious and may require assistance such as multiple psychiatric assessments; no mention is made of where funding could be provided for such necessary assistance.”

Quick links

18/4/11 - Guidance published on the handling of vulnerable witnesses, victims and defendants in court - review by Nina Grahame of the report "Raising the Bar" (published April 2011 by the Advocacy Training Council).



Right menu

  What's New?  
 

Save UK Justice resources
- what's it all about?
- Links to briefing papers
- Template MP letters
- Consultation responses 

Latest GCN legal bulletins
Housing (Mar 2013)
Crime (May 2013)

LASPO resources
Quick Guide to LASPO 2012 Part 3 (re: crime)
Quick Guide to LASPO 2012 for Housing Law
Quick Guide to LASPO 2012 for Immigration Law

Now on Twitter @gcnchambers

Seminar: Ways to do legally aided welfare rights work now there's no legal aid for welfare rights M'cr 15/7/13 4CPD

18/6/13 David Campoin on manslaughter by gross negligence in medical context

10/6/13 Human Rights claim over bullet conviction mix-up

10/6/13 Hillsborough inquests start date confirmed

30/5/13 Criminal law update

29/5/13 GCN Transforming Legal Aid responses

27/5/13 Mark George QC reflects on a week of action against Legal Aid cuts

22/5/13 Damages for detention breaching Art 5(1) (Stickley v MOJ from 2011) transcript added

21/5/13 Mark Barlow on sex offences, moral panic and right to fair trial

16/5/13 Matt Stanbury on dangerous dogs, anti-social behaviour and miscarriages

15/5/13 Sarah Daley shortlisted for LALY 2013 awards

7/5/13 Sarah Daley on concerns over immigration JR curbs

2/5/13 Hillsborough inquests to be held in North West

15/4/13 Osborn & Booth (Parole Board oral hearings) in Supreme Court this week

25/3/13 2013 applications for 2014 pupillage

15/3/13 Accept Track Changes? (Housing bulletin)

12/3/13 Matt Stanbury on how long do sex offenders have to notify on release

5/3/13 Tom Royston on Universal Credit 

21/2/13 Pete Weatherby QC on jury trials / Vicky Pryce

14/2/13 IPP sentences - ECHR ruling stands as Grand Chamber rejects Government's application to appeal (James Wells & Lee)

12/2/13 Good qn? Some thoughts on expert evidence within injunction proceedings

6/3/13 Brigid Baillie on Gangbos two years on (Justice Gap)

4/2/13 Mark Barlow on Challenging Convictions for Historical Sexual Offences

1/2/13 GCN pupil Tom Royston at "Legal Advice in crisis" conference (M'cr) on 9/2/13

31/1/13 New Standard Contractual Terms

25/1/13 Ian Lawless miscarriage compensation test case succeeds

25/1/13 Ben McCormack on Public Sector Equality Duty

22/1/13 Mark George QC in "Miscarriages of justice and jury trials" debate at KCL London

3/1/13 Passionate about justice

3/1/13 Mark George QC on the new Hillsborough inquests

19/12/12 Hillsborough inquest verdicts quashed in High Court

19/12/12 Social media prosecution guidelines

18/12/12 Criminal Law update

10/12/12 New Sex Offenders Notification regime challenge

28/11/12 ECHR Grand Chamber: Vinter v UK (whole life, Art 3) - Pete Weatherby QC

28/11/12 Twitter and contempt

23/11/12 JR clampdown

15/11/12 Life sentence quashed for hospital order

13/11/12 Permission to appeal JR refusal (eviction)

Human Trafficking and the Law

5/11/12 Mark George QC death penalty lectures (Amicus)

2/11/12 NEW! Chambers & Partners 2013 rankings

31/10/12 Mark George QC: SYorks Police "out of control"

22/10/12 Orgreave miners and South Yorkshire Police (BBC)

18/10/12 Blogger ASBO quashed

4/10/12 "A Kafkaesque nightmare"

3/10/12 Extradition: fitness to plead

18/9/12 ECHR rules on IPPs

14/9/12 Criminalise squatting?

13/9/12 Hillsborough report

5/9/12 Sex offender notification

16/8/12 Assange extradition

16/8/12 Matt Stanbury / Ben McCormack audio recording of PLP JR North 2012 plenary

15/8/12 Admissibility of hearsay

18/7/12 Family immigration rules

11/7/12 David Campion joins

28/6/12 Fresh gynaecological evidence (S & Ors v R)

27/6/12 Wrongly accused

26/6/12 Juvenille murder in US

22/6/12 Talha Ahsan

13/6/12 Rape conviction quashed (Court of Appeal NI)

13/6/12 Dangerous dogs

23/5/12 Cautions, coppers & cons

18/5/12 Equal pay

18/5/12 "Justice on the cheap"

14/5/12 Sharing JR

14/5/12 Why we do what we do

9/5/12 Mullings-Sewell inquest

8/5/12 F.A.C.T

23/4/12 Brighton Declaration

19/4/12 Belfast H-Rights event

18/4/12 ECHR reform (BBC)

12/4/12 Mark George QC - Visiting practitioner at Centre for American Legal Studies

11/4/12 Abu Hamza (BBC)

2/4/12 New QC

29/3/12 What is an IPP

8/3/12 Trafficking legal f/work

1/2/12 NEPB CoA latest

27/1/12 Death by incarceration

19/1/12 Loss of control

5/1/12 Double jeopardy

23/12/11 "Sickie" juror

20/12/11 Police on jury

14/12/11 Joint enterprise

9/12/11 UKBA "unfair" and "obscure" decisions quashed

5/12/11 2005 IPP quashed

18/11/11 Surveillance laws

16/11/11 Distance learning policy unlawful (HMP Wakefield)

28/10/11 Indirect discrimination

18/10/11 Squatting reform

18/10/11 Riot appeals

12/10/11 New Ogden Tables

6/10/11 Supergrass evidence

3/10/11 PB "mistake of fact"

28/9/11 Teacher cleared

4/8/11 Learning disability

22/7/11 Murder of burglar (ITV)

21/7/11 Trafficking offences

16/6/11 Facebook juror

26/5/11 Fasting prisoner, Art 9

29/3/11 Teacher arrest unlawful

3/3/11 Sex Offenders Register

14/2/11 Bahrain: BHRC report

8/2/11 Litigants in person

1/2/11 EHRC Preferred Counsel

7/1/11 Mark Barlow in Rook & Ward on Sexual Offences (4th)

4/1/11 Osborn & Booth

Macdonald's Immigration Law & Practice (8th ed.)

23/11/10 Sexual orientation

3/11/10 Pinnock judgment

19/4/10 Hannah McIntyre

16/12/09 Third party support

16/12/09 Sonny Lodge inquiry

30/11/09 IPP transfer- Guittard

9/9/09 Michael Shields released

16/6/09 Murder quashed

12/11/08 Pro-bono hero

23/10/08 "Small but beautiful"

9/9/08 Dog "Rocky" not guilty

4/7/08 Posthumous appeal

22/11/07 Mesothelioma ruling

12/04/06 Oral sex in public

 > Go to News headlines

Privacy Policy